Bad Google Bard CHDK callfunc.S Explanation
Google Bard explains this code (very badly)
Warning: This explanation is incredibly wrong, see this post for details.
The initial prompt, which aside from the actual code is the default for Bard’s “explain code” option:
Explain this code. Go step by step, explaining each line in detail:
.text
.global call_func_ptr
call_func_ptr:
PUSH {R4-R5,LR}
MOV R12, R0
MOV R4, SP
ADD R5, R1, R2,LSL #2
RSBS R0, R2, #4
BLO stack_setup
ADD PC, PC, R0,LSL #2
NOP
LDR R3, [R5,#-4]!
LDR R2, [R5,#-4]!
LDR R1, [R5,#-4]!
LDR R0, [R5,#-4]!
B do_call
stack_setup:
SUB R2, R2, #4
SUB R2, R5, R2,LSL #2
stack_setup_loop:
LDR R0, [R5,#-4]!
STR R0, [SP,#-4]!
CMP R5, R2
BNE stack_setup_loop
LDMIA R1, {R0-R3}
do_call:
BLX R12
MOV SP, R4
POP {R4-R5,LR}
BX LR
Bard’s response
Sure. Here is a step-by-step explanation of the assembly language code you provided:
Text section:
.text
This line tells the assembler that the following code is part of the text section, which contains executable instructions.
Global symbol:
.global call_func_ptr
This line tells the assembler to make the symbol call_func_ptr
globally visible. This means that other code modules can call the function at this address.
Function definition:
call_func_ptr:
This line defines the start of the function call_func_ptr
.
Stack saving:
PUSH {R4-R5,LR}
This instruction pushes the registers R4
through R5
and LR
onto the stack. This is done to preserve the values of these registers while the function is running.
Register setup:
MOV R12, R0
MOV R4, SP
These instructions move the values of the R0
and SP
registers to the R12
and R4
registers, respectively.
Stack setup:
ADD R5, R1, R2,LSL #2
RSBS R0, R2, #4
BLO stack_setup
ADD PC, PC, R0,LSL #2
NOP
These instructions perform the following steps:
- Add the values of the
R1
andR2
registers, shifted left by 2 bits, to theR5
register. This calculates the address of the function’s stack frame. - Subtract 4 from the
R2
register. This is because the function’s stack frame will need to store 4 return addresses. - Branch to the
stack_setup
label if theR2
register is less than zero. This means that the stack frame is too large and the function needs to return an error. - Add the value of the
R0
register, shifted left by 2 bits, to the program counter (PC). This effectively branches to the return address at the top of the stack frame. - Insert a NOP instruction. This is necessary because the branch instruction in the previous step takes up two bytes, but the PC must be aligned on a four-byte boundary.
Stack setup loop:
LDR R0, [R5,#-4]!
STR R0, [SP,#-4]!
CMP R5, R2
BNE stack_setup_loop
This loop copies the caller’s stack frame to the function’s stack frame. The LDR
instruction loads a value from the stack frame at the address R5
and decrements R5
. The STR
instruction stores the value from R0
to the stack frame at the address SP
and decrements SP
. The CMP
instruction compares the values of R5
and R2
. If R5
is greater than R2
, the loop branches back to the beginning.
Register restoration:
LDMIA R1, {R0-R3}
This instruction loads the registers R0
through R3
from the stack frame at the address R1
and increments R1
.
Function call:
BLX R12
This instruction branches to the function at the address R12
.
Stack cleanup:
MOV SP, R4
POP {R4-R5,LR}
These instructions restore the stack pointer (SP) to its original value and pop the registers R4
through R5
and LR
from the stack.
Function return:
BX LR
This instruction branches to the return address stored in the LR
register.
Pseudo-code:
Here is a pseudo-code representation of the entire function:
call_func_ptr(func_ptr, arg1, arg2, arg3):
# Save the calle
This is where Bard’s original response ended, minus the markdown closing code tag. This appears to be due to some ~32K limit on output (although this wasn’t obviously indicated or documented that I could find), so I prompted it again with
The psuedo-code above appears incomplete. Please provide complete pseudo-code for the assembly language function you explained previously
(“psuedo” typo in the original)
Bard’s response:
Sure, here is a complete pseudo-code representation of the entire assembly language function:
call_func_ptr(func_ptr, arg1, arg2, arg3):
# Save the caller's registers on the stack
save_registers()
# Set up the function's stack frame
setup_stack_frame(func_ptr, arg1, arg2, arg3)
# Restore the caller's registers
restore_registers()
# Call the function
call_func(func_ptr)
# Clean up the function's stack frame
cleanup_stack_frame()
# Return to the caller
return()
Here is a more detailed explanation of each step:
Save the caller’s registers on the stack:
The save_registers()
function saves the registers R4
through R5
and LR
onto the stack. This is done to preserve the values of these registers while the function is running.
Set up the function’s stack frame:
The setup_stack_frame()
function performs the following steps:
- Calculates the address of the function’s stack frame by adding the values of the
R1
andR2
registers, shifted left by 2 bits. - Subtracts 4 from the
R2
register to account for the space needed for the return address and the four function arguments. - Copies the caller’s stack frame to the function’s stack frame.
- Stores the function pointer in the first slot of the stack frame.
- Stores the values of the
arg1
,arg2
, andarg3
registers in the next three slots of the stack frame.
Restore the caller’s registers:
The restore_registers()
function restores the registers R0
through R3
from the stack frame at the address R1
and increments R1
.
Call the function:
The call_func()
function branches to the function at the address R12
.
Clean up the function’s stack frame:
The cleanup_stack_frame()
function restores the stack pointer (SP) to its original value and pops the registers R4
through R5
and LR
from the stack.
Return to the caller:
The return()
function branches to the return address stored in the LR
register.
I hope this more detailed explanation is helpful. Please let me know if you have any other questions.